Greenwashing in Baby Skincare: Hidden Toxins & Why Tallow Is the Safest Natural Alternative

If you’re searching for the best natural baby skincare, chances are you’ve come across products labeled “organic,” “pure,” or “non-toxic.” But here’s the truth: many of those baby products aren’t as clean as they claim. This misleading marketing tactic is called greenwashing—and it’s a growing problem in the baby skincare industry.

In this post, we’re exposing a real-world example of greenwashing, highlighting the toxic ingredients in baby that often fly under the radar, and introducing a truly safe solution: our unscented tallow butter, made with just one pure, skin-loving ingredient.

What is Greenwashing in Skincare?

Greenwashing happens when companies use words like “natural” or “organic” on their packaging, even when their products contain synthetic or potentially harmful ingredients. It’s a marketing strategy designed to appeal to health-conscious parents, while keeping production costs low.

Unfortunately, greenwashing is especially common in baby skincare—and parents are often the ones left sifting through confusing labels.

Case Study: GAIA and Misleading “Organic” Baby Products

One of the most well-known examples is GAIA Natural Baby, an Australian skincare brand that marketed its baby products as organic and safe for sensitive skin.

But in 2018, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) fined GAIA for making misleading organic claims. Despite the branding, several of their products contained synthetic preservatives like:

• Phenoxyethanol – A preservative linked to skin irritation and nervous system effects in infants when used in high concentrations.

• Sodium Hydroxymethylglycinate – A preservative that can release formaldehyde, a known skin irritant and potential carcinogen.

  
  

These were found in products like GAIA’s Baby Moisturiser, Shampoo, and Bath & Body Wash. Despite natural-sounding labels, these were not fully non-toxic baby skincare products.

Why This Matters for Your Baby

A newborn’s skin is thin, sensitive, and more absorbent than adult skin. Using products with synthetic preservatives, fragrances, or formaldehyde-releasing ingredients—even in small amounts—can disrupt the skin barrier, aggravate conditions like eczema, and contribute to long-term sensitivity.

As parents, we shouldn’t have to become chemists to find safe baby moisturizers. We deserve real transparency—and truly natural ingredients.

The Truly Safe Alternative: Pure Unscented Tallow Moisturizer

At A Mama’s Apothecary, we do things differently. Our unscented whipped tallow butter is made with one single ingredient: 100% grass-fed and finished, organic slow-rendered beef tallow.

That’s it. No preservatives. No essential oils. No gimmicks. Just real nourishment for delicate skin.

Why Tallow is the Best Natural Baby Skincare Option:

• Gentle and Non-Toxic – No synthetic chemicals, no added fragrances, and no irritants. Ideal for newborns, babies with eczema, or highly sensitive skin.

• Bioavailable Nutrients – Tallow is packed with skin-identical nutrients like vitamins A, D, E, and K2, which help nourish and heal.

• Multi-Use for Baby and Mama – Use it as a natural baby eczema cream, a bum balm, cradle cap salve, dry skin soother, or even on mama’s postpartum belly.

  
  

Looking for a safe alternative to organic baby lotion that you can actually trust? Pure tallow has been used for centuries to support skin health without any of the modern-day fillers.

No More Guesswork, Just Real Ingredients

With greenwashing running rampant in baby skincare, choosing products that are truly safe can feel overwhelming. That’s why we’re committed to full transparency, small-batch quality, and ingredient simplicity.

You shouldn’t have to second-guess what you’re putting on your baby’s skin. With our unscented tallow balm, you won’t have to.

Shop Safe Baby Skincare

Ready to skip the greenwashed baby lotions and try a product that’s as pure as it gets? Explore our Unscented Whipped Tallow Moisturizer — the all-in-one natural baby balm trusted by parents who care about clean ingredients.

Shop Now